She Wanted to Reward Her Team—But Profit Sharing Backfired – Disclaimer: This is a fictionalized story based on real challenges faced by business owners. It’s for informational purposes only.
She Wanted to Reward Her Team—But Profit Sharing Backfired
Tanya’s marketing firm had a great year. Wanting to share the success, she rolled out a profit-sharing plan for her top employees. It was simple: a percentage of year-end profit would go to the team.
But here’s what she didn’t know:
- She didn’t properly define profit for tax purposes
- No legal structure supported the plan
- She hadn’t reserved enough cash for distributions
- The IRS treated some payouts as improper compensation
What started as a generous gesture turned into a year-end scramble—with surprise tax bills for her team, disallowed deductions, and payroll reporting issues that triggered a compliance review.
Her goodwill… cost her.
Profit Sharing Needs a Plan
Profit-sharing can be a powerful retention and reward tool—but it must be:
- Structured legally and financially
- Aligned with IRS and ERISA requirements
- Backed by proper documentation and reporting
Otherwise, you could face:
- Tax misclassification
- Disallowed deductions
- Team dissatisfaction
- Legal and financial penalties
How MSM Advisors Helps
We help businesses turn profit-sharing ideas into strategic, tax-smart plans. MSM works with your legal and HR advisors to:
- Define profit in tax-compliant terms
- Structure bonuses, distributions, or retirement plan options
- Set up documentation and reserve strategies
- Align incentives with your long-term business goals
Whether it’s a bonus, K-1, or formal plan—we make sure your generosity works for your business, not against it.
Great leaders reward their teams. Great CPAs help them do it wisely.
Talk to MSM Advisors to design a plan that works.
Whether your business is small, mid-sized, or a start-up, MSM Advisors is ready to help you move your business forward with a customized blend of services that match your level of need. See our list of services here.
Visit our Facebook page here –> https://www.facebook.com/msmcpa
Visit us on LinkedIn here -> https://www.linkedin.com/company/michael-s-moffitt-p-c-/
